Compare / the main question

Recycled vs new pallets

Half the price, the same footprint, the same racking behaviour and a fifth of the carbon — against uniform appearance, predictable tare weight and tighter tolerances. Here is the whole comparison, including the cases where new wins.

Long rows of clean, freshly graded pallets stacked high in a bright warehouse — Grade A pool, ready to ship

Request a quote

Put this page into a quote.

The fields below reach the same yard team that wrote this page. Tell us the size, the count and the grade you think you need — we will confirm it or correct it, in writing, within one business day.

Portland, OR · email only, no phone

First name *

Last name *

Email *A mailbox you actually read — this is how we reply.

Phone *US or Canada, 10 digits — format (503) 274-0900.

Company

Address

City

State / Province

Postal code *US ZIP or Canadian code.

Select service *

Product type *Type freely or pick from the list.

Quantity *Whole number — per month or one-time.

Grade

Message

Required fields are marked *. We validate every entry, so a typo in your email or ZIP will be flagged before the request is sent. Read our privacy note.

This is the decision almost every pallet buyer actually faces, and it is usually made on instinct rather than arithmetic. The instinct says new is safer. The arithmetic says a Grade A recycled pallet carries the same load, lasts most of the same distance, and costs roughly half as much.

We are a reuse company, so read this page with that in mind — which is exactly why we have published the five situations where we will tell you to buy new instead.

Detail

What this means in practice

Where recycled wins outright
General freight, floor stacking, closed loops, one-way shipping, agriculture, construction, and any operation where a quarter-inch tolerance is plenty.
Where new genuinely wins
Tolerances tighter than ±1/4", footprints that do not exist secondhand, audited white-wood policies, net-weight operations, and contract terms imposed by your customer.
Where the answer is neither
Wash-down and deep-freeze lines, where plastic is honestly better, and very heavy machinery, which wants a bolted skid rather than a pallet.
The myth worth killing
That recycled wood cannot be export compliant. ISPM-15 compliance comes from heat treatment and a registered stamp, not from the age of the fibre.

Specifications

Numbers you can plan around

Published, honoured, and quoted back to you in writing on every order.

48×40 GMA footprint, Pacific Northwest, 2026. Cost index against a new pallet of the same build.
Attribute	New	Grade A recycled	Grade B recycled	Remanufactured
Cost index	100	45–55	30–40	25–35
Dynamic load	2,800 lb	2,800 lb	2,200 lb	2,000 lb
Racked load	2,200 lb	2,200 lb	1,500 lb	1,200 lb
Dimensional tolerance	± 1/8"	± 1/4"	± 1/2"	± 1/2"
Tare consistency	Within ounces	± 2 lb	± 3 lb	± 4 lb
Appearance	Uniform, bright	Greyed, consistent	Visibly used	Mixed boards
Trips before repair	15–20	9–14	7–11	5–8
Repairable	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Carbon per use	14.2 kg CO₂e	3.1 kg	3.1 kg	4.8 kg
ISPM-15 possible	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Lead time	5–9 days	Same day	Same day	1–3 days
Reuse content	0%	100%	100%	95–100%

Comparison

Side by side

New pallet — cost per trip index5.6
Grade A recycled — cost per trip4.3
Grade B recycled — cost per trip3.8
Reman — cost per trip5.0

What you are actually buying when you buy new

Three things: dimensional consistency to roughly an eighth of an inch, a tare weight that varies by ounces rather than pounds, and uniform appearance. Everything else — load rating, footprint, repairability, export compliance — a graded recycled pallet gives you too.

Those three things are worth real money in exactly three environments: automated handling, net-weight operations, and audits with a documented white-wood requirement. Outside those, you are paying a 100% premium for attributes that do not touch your operation.

The hidden cost that flips the comparison the other way

New hardwood pallets are heavy. A southern yellow pine or mixed hardwood 48×40 can weigh twenty pounds more than the Douglas fir recycled unit it replaced. On a weight-constrained lane running 600 units a month, that is six tonnes of paid-for wood that carries nothing.

So the comparison is not simply price versus quality. On some lanes a recycled fir pallet is both cheaper to buy and cheaper to ship, which is an unusual combination in packaging.

How to run the test yourself

Buy one truckload of Grade A recycled alongside your normal new order. Measure one in ten of each: both dimensions, the diagonal, protruding fasteners, bottom-board integrity. Then track damage and rejections for one quarter on each pool.

We have watched this test run perhaps thirty times. The recycled pool loses on appearance every time and loses on damage approximately never. If it does lose, tell us, because that is a grading failure on our side and we want to know.

Process

How recycled vs new order actually happens

No sales team, no discovery call, no CRM sequence. We have no telephone, so everything below happens in writing and stays searchable afterwards.

What we need: footprint, grade, count, ZIP, and how the pallet is handled.
Nice to have: a photo, your dock height, whether you run forklifts or jacks.
Not needed: a purchase order, an account, or a phone conversation.

01
You send the form
Every form on this site is the same form and reaches the same yard team. Required fields are validated as you type, so a mistyped ZIP or email is caught before anything is sent.
02
We check today's stock
Used pallet availability moves daily. You get a real count and a real date rather than a list price that was true last quarter.
03
A written quote, within one business day
Price per unit by grade, freight itemised separately, delivery window, and any honest reservations we have about the specification you asked for.
04
Delivery, count, paperwork
Signed count sheet on arrival, weight ticket where relevant, and a diversion certificate for anything we collect for recycling.

PalletLinker published ratings. Quoted back to you in writing on every order. Racked figures assume edge support only, evenly distributed, no overhang.
Pallet	Static	Dynamic	Racked	Tare	Stack height
48×40 GMA Grade A	8,000 lb	2,800 lb	2,200 lb	33–37 lb	3 high loaded
48×40 GMA Grade B	6,500 lb	2,200 lb	1,500 lb	30–36 lb	2 high loaded
48×40 block, 4-way	9,000 lb	2,500 lb	2,400 lb	37–41 lb	4 high loaded
EPAL / Euro 1	8,800 lb	3,300 lb	2,200 lb	48–55 lb	3 high loaded
42×42 beverage	7,500 lb	2,600 lb	1,900 lb	35–39 lb	3 high loaded
48×48 drum	9,500 lb	3,000 lb	2,300 lb	40–45 lb	2 high loaded
36×36 nursery deck	4,500 lb	1,400 lb	900 lb	24–28 lb	2 high loaded
48×20 half pallet	3,000 lb	1,400 lb	900 lb	18–22 lb	2 high loaded
Remanufactured 48×40	6,000 lb	2,000 lb	1,200 lb	30–38 lb	2 high loaded
Heavy skid 96×48	16,000 lb	12,000 lb	Not for racking	95–130 lb	1 high

01
Published specifications
Grade definitions, dimensional tolerances and racked load ratings in writing. Most yards will not publish a racked figure at all.
02
Hand graded, four-hour triage
Two graders per line, flipped and sounded. Every inbound load is triaged within four working hours so nothing rots in a mystery pile.
03
Zero landfill, measured
Weighed in, weighed out, reconciled monthly. Zero pounds landfilled in 2025, with a certificate you can hand to an auditor.
04
Everything in writing
No phone line by choice. Every price, date and commitment lives in an email you can search, forward and hold us to.
05
Repair before replacement
A repair bay, a kiln, a de-nailer and a grinder on site. Repairing a pallet avoids roughly 11 kg CO₂e and costs you half of new.
06
Traceable by stamp
Every unit carries a Pallet Passport ID burned into a stringer. Type it in and read its species, cycles, repairs and carbon ledger.

Receiving

What to check on delivery

Eleven minutes on the first three deliveries sets the tone for the whole relationship. Do this with any supplier, including us.

Check	How	Pass	If it fails
Overall size	Tape measure, both dimensions, one pallet in ten	Within 1/4" (Grade A) or 1/2" (Grade B)	Note it on the delivery ticket
Squareness	Steel square in two opposite corners	Within 1/4" on the diagonal	Reject the unit; we replace next route
Protruding nails	Palm flat across the top deck	Nothing catches	Reject — this is what tears packaging
Bottom boards	Flip one pallet in ten	No split through a nail line	Reject; it will fail in a rack
Moisture	Lift one. Wet pallets are 8–10 lb heavier	Feels dry, sounds sharp	Floor stack to dry, do not rack at rating
Mould or staining	Visual, both decks	Weathering only, no fuzz	Reject for any food-contact use
Grade mix	Count against the delivery note	Matches what you ordered	Ask for the count sheet to be corrected

Write failures on the delivery ticket rather than calling — a written record is the only thing that reliably changes supplier behaviour, and we replace rejected units on the next route with no restocking charge.

Avoid these

Six expensive mistakes

Every one of these has cost a customer real money in front of us.

01
Buying on unit price alone
Purchase price is 5–15% of total cost per trip. Tare weight, damage rate and receiving-dock rework are usually larger line items, and none of them appear on a quote comparison.
02
Accepting overhang
A load extending even an inch past the deck transfers weight into the packaging instead of the pallet. Case compression strength drops sharply and the damage appears three handling events later, in somebody else's warehouse.
03
Racking on a dynamic rating
Dynamic is what a pallet carries while being moved. Racked — supported only at its edges — is smaller and is the only number that matters in beam racking. Ask for it in writing.
04
Specifying Grade A out of habit
For one-way shipping, floor stacking and closed loops, Grade B does the same job for roughly 20% less. Over-specifying is paying for appearance.
05
Storing pallets on bare ground
Two spare pallets as a base and a tarp that reaches the sides will keep a stack usable through a Portland winter. A soaked pallet gains nine pounds of paid freight weight and loses stiffness.
06
Forgetting that dunnage needs a stamp
On export loads the bracing, blocking and chocks are solid wood packaging too. One untreated board can hold an entire container at a foreign port.

The yard

What stands behind this page

14kpallets graded monthlytwo hand-grading lines
1,100heat treated per dayISPM-15, chart recorded
4.1M lbwood diverted last year68% reused whole
0 lblandfilled in 2025weighed and reconciled

What this means for your reporting

Reuse is the cheapest emissions reduction available in logistics, and it is also the easiest to document. We model a new 48×40 softwood pallet at 14.2 kg CO₂e — lumber production, fasteners, assembly and delivery — and a reuse cycle at 3.1 kg, covering collection, repair materials, yard overhead and redelivery. The difference, 11 kg CO₂e per reuse, is the figure we publish.

We also publish the caveat: that figure assumes a reused pallet genuinely displaces the manufacture of a new one. Economists call the gap leakage, and nobody in this industry can honestly claim it is zero. We think displacement is high because the pallet market is regional and price-responsive, but we will not pretend it is perfect.

Which is why we lead with the number that needs no assumptions: measured landfill diversion. Landfilled wood decomposes anaerobically and releases methane, roughly 28 times worse than CO₂ over a century. Keeping four million pounds of wood out of a hole in the ground is a benefit you can weigh.

Per-unit figures

New pallet: 14.2 kg CO₂e (range 12.8–16.1)
Reused graded pallet: 3.1 kg CO₂e
Repaired customer-owned: 2.2 kg CO₂e
Avoided per reuse: 11 kg CO₂e, published
Wood kept in service: 33–37 lb per unit
Biogenic carbon stored: ~26 kg CO₂-equivalent

The full derivation

Questions

Asked often

Does recycled wood carry pest risk?

Not when it is heat treated, which kills wood-boring organisms at 56 °C core for 30 minutes. Untreated wood of any age carries the same theoretical risk, new or used.

Will my customer notice?

Receiving docks check for protruding nails, squareness and missing boards. In fifteen years we have never had a customer's customer complain about pallet colour.

Can I mix pools?

Yes, and many customers do: new for an automated line, Grade A for racking, Grade B for one-way outbound. One supplier, three pools, three prices.

Questions

What people ask about recycled vs new pallets

What is the minimum order or pickup?

No hard minimum for collection at the yard — come and take four pallets on a Saturday morning if you like. For delivery it is 50 units inside Portland metro and 150 outside it, because the truck has to earn its diesel. Outside our 180-mile fleet radius we quote through partner yards and freight, with the lane itemised.

How fast can this happen?

Standard 48×40 Grade A and B stock: same day for pickup, next day for metro delivery. Block pallets one to three days. Custom builds five to nine business days; engineered runs two to three weeks. Heat treatment is same day for booked batches and 48 hours standard. Written quotes always come back within one business day.

Why is there no phone number anywhere?

Because verbal quotes get remembered differently by different people. Since 2018 every price, date and commitment we make exists in an email you can search and forward. Most customers dislike it for about a month and then prefer it. Everything else happens in person at 3821 NW St Helens Rd, Portland, OR 97210.

Can I inspect before committing?

Please do. Visit the yard by email arrangement — closed-toe boots required, hi-vis provided — or ask for photographs of the actual pool your order would come from. We would rather lose an order than have a customer discover a surprise on their dock.

What documentation comes with it?

A written quote, a signed count sheet by grade, a weight ticket where material is weighed, heat-treatment certificates for treated batches (archived seven years), and a monthly diversion certificate for anything we collect for recycling — measured pounds kept out of landfill, which is the figure your ESG report actually needs.

What will you refuse to do?

Take methyl-bromide fumigated, chemically contaminated or fire-damaged wood. Buy marked rental-pool pallets, which belong to their operator. Promise same-day delivery outside the metro. Or quote a grade we do not think will survive your handling — we will specify downward and explain why.

Vocabulary

Terms used on this page

Defined the way a yard uses them, not the way a standards document does.

Block pallet: A pallet supported by nine solid blocks rather than stringers, giving true four-way entry and better racked performance.
Bolster: A squared timber used to block and brace loads inside trailers and containers. We re-saw ours from retired stringers.
Chamfer: The bevelled edge on a bottom deck board that lets a pallet jack roll on without catching.
Companion stringer: A second timber nailed alongside a cracked stringer to span the damage and restore the load path.
Core: Low-grade pallet material bought for board and fibre recovery rather than resale.
Closed loop: A pallet population circulating between known points and returning. Cycle time, not consumption, governs pool size.
Deck board: The boards nailed across stringers or blocks forming the top and bottom surfaces of a pallet.
De-nailer: The machine that separates deck boards from stringers and removes fasteners before fibre recovery.

The full glossary, 36 terms

Long reads

From the journal · written in the yard

Decision table

Five ways to get a pallet, compared honestly

Including the two we do not sell. Cost index is against a new wooden pallet of the same footprint.

Indicative figures for a 48×40 footprint in the Pacific Northwest, 2026. Rental pool economics vary by contract and are deliberately shown as a range.
Option	Cost index	Trips	Repairable	Carbon per use	Best for	Watch out for
Grade A recycled	45–55	9–14 then repair	Yes	3.1 kg	Almost everything	Colour varies; tare varies by a few pounds
Grade B recycled	30–40	7–11 then repair	Yes	3.1 kg	One-way, floor stacking, closed loops	Lower racked rating (1,500 lb)
Remanufactured	25–35	5–8	Yes	4.8 kg	One-way on a budget	Visibly mixed boards; 1,200 lb racked
New wooden	100	15–20 then repair	Yes	14.2 kg	Tight tolerances, audits, odd sizes	Pays for appearance you may not need
Plastic	500–1,000	30–100	No	High embodied, low per-use	Wash-down, deep freeze, pharma	Cracks end its life; not repairable
Rental pool	Per-trip fee	Managed	By operator	Operator's figure	Exchange networks, retail mandates	Pallets are not yours; losses are chargeable

We sell the first four and supply plastic where a wash-down line genuinely needs it. We do not operate a rental pool, and we will not buy marked pool pallets from you — they belong to their operator. Full comparisons

Worked example

Cost per trip, calculated properly

A real comparison for a plant shipping 600 pallets a month on a weight-sensitive lane. Copy the method, not the numbers.

Illustrative. Your lane rate, damage rate and disposal cost will differ — the point is that unit price is the smallest line in the table.
Line	New pallet	Grade A recycled	Grade B recycled	Note
Unit purchase price (index)	100	50	35	The only number most procurement systems compare
Trips before repair	15–20	9–14	7–11	New lasts longer; it also costs twice as much
Purchase cost per trip (index)	5.6	4.3	3.8	Price divided by trips
Tare weight	36 lb	35 lb	33 lb	Recycled fir is often lighter than new hardwood
Freight weight penalty	Baseline	Neutral	−3 lb/unit	Only matters on weight-limited lanes
Expected damage rate	0.3%	0.3%	0.4%	Graded stock behaves; ungraded stock does not
Receiving rejections	Rare	Rare	Occasional	Graded + written tolerance removes most of this
End-of-life cost	0	0	0	We collect and pay or collect free — never a disposal fee
Documentation value	None	Diversion certificate	Diversion certificate	Reportable ESG outcome at no extra cost

Purchase price share of total cost5–15%
Freight weight share~30%
Damage & rework share~38%
Handling labour share~20%

Build this yourself

One row per option, six columns: unit price, tare weight, expected trips, damage rate, rejection risk, disposal cost. Multiply out across annual volume. It takes an afternoon, the cheapest unit price almost never wins, and we will happily help build it — including with numbers that do not favour us.

The full article

Diagnostics

Read the damage, fix the cause

Damage patterns are not random. Each one points at a specific handling behaviour, and fixing the behaviour is worth more than fixing the pallets.

What you see	What it almost always means	What to change	Cost to fix
Split lead boards at one end	Forks driven in too fast and too high	Operator training; dock lighting. Usually one shift is responsible	Free
Torn stringer notches	Pallet jacks entering notched stringers at an angle	Specify block pallets with true four-way entry	Spec change
Bottom boards ripped off cleanly	Pallets dragged rather than lifted, or frozen to a cold-store floor	Floor condition, forklift capacity at peak	Low
Crushed corner blocks	Stacks higher than the rating, or uneven loads on one corner	Stack-height policy; centre the load	Free
Out of square, nothing broken	Racking loading pallets diagonally — beams at different heights	Rack survey. This one is worth chasing	Medium
Mould in the middle of a stack	Wet pallets stacked tight with no airflow	Store off the ground, cover the top, leave side gaps	Low
Protruding nails tearing cases	Ungraded stock, or units repaired without re-checking	Buy graded; reject on the ticket	Free
Deck boards cupping	Moisture cycling between a freezer and a humid dock	Kiln-dried pool; helical fasteners	Spec change

Keep thirty of your own broken pallets aside for a month and photograph the damage. Patterns appear quickly. We do this analysis free with any repair quote, because a customer whose damage rate halves buys from us for a decade.

Storage

Keeping pallets usable through a wet winter

Portland takes about 36 inches of rain a year and most of it lands between November and March. You do not need a building to survive that — you need three habits.

Off the ground: Two spare pallets as a base. Anything touching soil wicks water and rots from the bottom layer up.
Covered on top: A tarp that actually reaches the sides. Rain enters a stack from above, not from the side.
Air gaps, not a seal: A sealed tarp traps condensation and produces the mould problem you were avoiding. Leave the sides open.
Away from drip lines: Anything under a roofline drip edge stays wet all winter, regardless of what you cover it with.
Aligned with the wind: Stacks oriented with prevailing wind dry noticeably faster. Free, and it works.
Rotate the pile: First in, first out. The bottom of an untouched stack is where pallets go to die.

What moisture does, measured on our own scale and grading line.
Condition	Weight	Stiffness	Rack it?
Kiln dried (≤19% MC)	33 lb	Full rating	Yes
Air dried, covered	35 lb	Full rating	Yes
Damp, uncovered 2 weeks	39 lb	Reduced	Floor stack
Rain-soaked	45 lb	Materially reduced	No — let it dry
Frozen wet	45 lb+	Unpredictable	No

Nine pounds of water per pallet is nine pounds of freight you pay to move. Across 600 units that is more than two and a half tonnes of water on a truck. Field notes on moisture

Timing

The pallet year in the Pacific Northwest

Supply and price both move with the seasons. Knowing the shape of the year is worth more than negotiating hard in October.

Month	What the region is doing	Pool depth	What to do
January	Everything quiet; recycling inflow steady	Deep	Best buying window of the year. We stockpile now
February	Repair bay catching up	Deep	Lock quarterly pricing; book spring nursery stock
March	Nursery season begins	Tightening on 36×36	Spring stock should already be reserved
April	Nursery peak; landscaping starts	Tight on nursery decks	Mulch and bedding demand rises sharply
May	Nursery winding down	Normalising	Good month for custom builds and crate projects
June	Berry harvest	Normal	Watch for short-notice agricultural requests
July	Berries, early stone fruit	Normal	Forecast your October number now
August	Pre-harvest build-up	Normalising down	Harvest slots allocated this month
September	Hazelnut and grape harvest begins	Tight	Reserved stock only. Spot buyers struggle
October	Peak harvest; cider apples	Tightest of the year	Do not start here. Everyone calls at once
November	Harvest ends; rain begins	Recovering	Grading gets stricter; covered storage fills
December	Retail peak, agriculture stops	Deep again	Mulch demand collapses, biomass rises

Lifecycle

Eleven years in the life of one pallet

A composite built from real Passport records. Individual units vary enormously; the shape does not.

Year 0
Built
Douglas fir from a mill inside 180 miles. Seven top boards, five bottom, three stringers, helical nails, 2,800 lb dynamic.
Year 0–2
Trips 1–4
Beverage route work. Loaded, racked, unloaded, returned. Colour starts to grey; nothing structural changes.
Year 3
First inspection failure
A lead board splits at a nail line. Twenty-minute fix: replacement deck board, re-square, re-stamp. Graded B from here.
Year 3–6
Trips 5–9
Nursery and agricultural work, where deck gaps matter more than appearance. Spends two winters partly outdoors.
Year 7
Companion stringer
A stringer cracks. A second timber is fitted alongside, spanning the crack. Measurably stiffer than before.
Year 7–10
Trips 10–13
Local one-way freight. Tare weight has drifted up a pound from accumulated moisture cycling.
Year 11
Retired from carrying
Two bottom boards gone, deck softening. Economic repair ends here. Chalk line through the whole pallet.
Year 11
Dismantled
De-nailed board by board. Clear boards to the fabrication shop; structural stock back to the repair bay as donor material.
Year 11
Recovered
What is left goes through a magnet and a grinder: mulch, bedding shavings, biomass fuel. The nails go to a scrap partner four miles away.
Year 11+
Still working
The best boards are now shelving in a bottle shop, carrying its Passport ID burned into the end grain.

Thirteen trips, two repairs, roughly 143 kg CO₂e avoided against building thirteen new pallets, and nothing landfilled at the end. Look up a real record

Go deeper

Everything else on this site

Read the journal

Next step

Run the test on one truckload.

We will quote a Grade A load against your current new spec and tell you honestly which parts of your requirement recycled cannot meet.

Recycled vs new pallets

Put this page into a quote.

What this means in practice

Where recycled wins outright

Where new genuinely wins

Where the answer is neither

The myth worth killing

Numbers you can plan around

Side by side

What you are actually buying when you buy new

The hidden cost that flips the comparison the other way

How to run the test yourself

How recycled vs new order actually happens

You send the form

We check today's stock

A written quote, within one business day

Delivery, count, paperwork

Published specifications

Hand graded, four-hour triage

Zero landfill, measured

Everything in writing

Repair before replacement

Traceable by stamp

What to check on delivery

Six expensive mistakes

Buying on unit price alone

Accepting overhang

Racking on a dynamic rating

Specifying Grade A out of habit

Storing pallets on bare ground

Forgetting that dunnage needs a stamp

What stands behind this page

What this means for your reporting

Asked often

What people ask about recycled vs new pallets

Terms used on this page

From the journal · written in the yard

When new pallets are genuinely the right answer

A pallet glossary for people who have to buy them

How many pallets do you actually need? A sizing method that works

Pallet furniture, done properly: safety, species and finish

Five ways to get a pallet, compared honestly

Cost per trip, calculated properly

Read the damage, fix the cause

Keeping pallets usable through a wet winter

The pallet year in the Pacific Northwest

Eleven years in the life of one pallet

Built

Trips 1–4

First inspection failure

Trips 5–9

Companion stringer

Trips 10–13

Retired from carrying

Dismantled

Recovered

Still working

Go deeper

Everything else on this site

Run the test on one truckload.